Gay Key West
Bars & Clubs
Restaurants
Hotels
Shops
Arts
Beaches
History
Articles
Events

American Restaurants in Old Town

View Map
Filters
Photo of The Flaming Buoy Filet Co.

The Flaming Buoy Filet Co.

 (7 Ratings)

Fun restaurant with fabulous food

The buoy isn't the only thing flaming at this Old Town seafood joint. The restaurant has a large gay clientele, though...

Old Town · 1100 Packer St, Key West


Photo of Duffy's Steak & Lobster House

Duffy's Steak & Lobster House

 (6 Ratings)

Classic, delicious surf 'n turf menu

Duffy's serves fresh-catch seafood and Florida lobster, and juicy grilled steak. This is one of the traditional Key...

Old Town · 1007 Simonton St, Key West


Photo of Kelly's Bar Grill & Brewery

Kelly's Bar Grill & Brewery

 (3 Ratings)

Casual patio dining, Key West style

Kelly's is historic Key West. This mainstream bar & grill has a lush tropical outdoor courtyard and features lots of...

Old Town · 301 Whitehead St, Key West


Photo of Mr. Z's -Old Town

Mr. Z's -Old Town

 (2 Ratings)

Philly's best in Key West.

Mr. Z's has two locations, one in old town and one in new town. They serve up some great pizza and cheesesteaks.

Old Town · 501 Southard St, Key West


Photo of Mattheessen's

Mattheessen's

 (1 Rating)

Cookies, ice cream, key lime pie and marble slab fudge

There are two Mattheessen's locations in Key West--this spot is away from the tourists with good-quality food.

Old Town · 300 Front St, Key West


Photo of "Off The Hook" Grill

"Off The Hook" Grill

 No ratings yet

Seafood and eye candy

The seafood platters? Great! The service? Even greater! This LGBTQ-owned-and-operated oceanside outpost lives up to its...

Old Town · 920 Caroline St, Key West


Photo of Mangoes Restaurant

Mangoes Restaurant

 (2 Ratings)

Seafood medly

Mangoes isn't your average seafood restaurant. They've made a name for themselves in the local LGBTQ+...

2nd place in Best of GayCities 2023 - Drag Brunch

Old Town · 700 Duval St, Key West


Photo of Carriage Trade House

Carriage Trade House

 No ratings yet

They are open when they feel like it

Carriage Trade House is a true Key West institution. When they want to be open, they put a sign out front with the...

Old Town · 529 Eaton St., Key West


Map of American Restaurants in Old Town

Featured Articles

5 queer hangouts that welcome sober socializing

dry january

5 queer hangouts that welcome sober socializing

How far would you travel to savor these 5 queer chefs' cuisine?

first-class fare

How far would you travel to savor these 5 queer chefs' cuisine?

The secret is out, Mérida is Mexico's hottest up-and-coming queer destination

out in Mexico

The secret is out, Mérida is Mexico's hottest up-and-coming queer destination

Portland's quirky, progressive culture fosters an impressive culinary scene

foodie heaven

Portland's quirky, progressive culture fosters an impressive culinary scene

A taste of luxury: 5 Michelin-starred restaurants with LGBTQ+ chefs

A taste of luxury: 5 Michelin-starred restaurants with LGBTQ+ chefs

Top spots for a fast and fabulous brunch in sunny Miami

Top spots for a fast and fabulous brunch in sunny Miami

Make Ursula part of your world – James Beard nominee re-opens eatery in Brooklyn

Make Ursula part of your world – James Beard nominee re-opens eatery in Brooklyn

San Francisco pop-up restaurant transports diners to the world of 'Golden Girls'

San Francisco pop-up restaurant transports diners to the world of 'Golden Girls'


Gay Key West
Bars & Clubs
Restaurants
Hotels
Shops
Arts
Beaches
History
Articles
Events