Restaurants in Old Town · Page 2

Philly's best in Key West.

Mr. Z's has two locations, one in old town and one in new town. They serve up some great pizza and cheesesteaks.

Old Town · 501 Southard St, Key West

• $$
• $
• American
• pizza

Romantic indulgence

The name of this restaurant says it all. Sexually-suggestive names on the menu conjure naughty thoughts as you eat...

Old Town · 926 Simonton St, Key West

• $$

Cookies, ice cream, key lime pie and marble slab fudge

There are two Mattheessen's locations in Key West--this spot is away from the tourists with good-quality food.

Old Town · 300 Front St, Key West

• $$
• $
• American
• ice cream

Great vegetarian menu that satisfies

A delightful selection of vegetarian items adorns the menu of the Cafe. Popular with locals for its great menu and...

Old Town · 509 Southard St, Key West

• outdoor seating
• $
• Seafood
• coffee

Home of The World Famous Cuban Sandwich

Located at the unique crossroads of White and Virginia Streets, Sandy's Café stands as a jewel in the...

Old Town · 1026 White St, Key West

• $
• sandwiches
• ice cream
• casual
• dessert
• burgers
• fast & casual

This gem of the sea is culinary heaven.

A stylish neighborhood restaurant and wine bar serving day-caught seafood and other seasonally-inspired dishes....

Old Town · 632 Olivia St, Key West

• mixed LGBTQ+
• $$$
• Asian
• Fusion
• fine dining
• upscale
• luxe

Great coffee with a view

The iconic, waterfront Cuban Coffee Queen is famed for its delicious coffee just as much for its eye-catching ‘Key...

Old Town · 284 Margaret St, Naval Air Station Key West

• trans-friendly
• outdoor seating
• mixed gay/straight
• cafe
• BIPOC-owned

Seafood and eye candy

The seafood platters? Great! The service? Even greater! This LGBTQ-owned-and-operated oceanside outpost lives up to its...

Old Town · 920 Caroline St, Key West

• outdoor seating
• American
• Seafood
• LGBTQ+ owned
• women-led

Mangoes Restaurant

Seafood medly

Mangoes isn't your average seafood restaurant. They've made a name for themselves in the local LGBTQ+...

2nd place in Best of GayCities 2023 - Drag Brunch

Old Town · 700 Duval St, Key West

• outdoor seating
• mixed LGBTQ+
• mixed gay/straight
• $$
• American
• Seafood
• small plates
• brunch
• sandwiches
• good for groups
• lively
• romantic
• upscale
• fast & casual

They are open when they feel like it

Carriage Trade House is a true Key West institution. When they want to be open, they put a sign out front with the...

Old Town · 529 Eaton St., Key West

• $$
• American
• LGBTQ+ owned